Staten Island has never seen this much drama. Scarlett Johansson and Colin Jost debated over whether or not they should sell the ferry that the comedian bought with his fellow Staten Island native Pete Davidson.

During an appearance on Today With Jenna and Friends , Johansson was joined by Jost for the show's recurring "Great Debate" segment, in which two guests square off on a topic. For the final round, host Jenna Bush Hager threw the couple for a loop by asking them: "Staten Island ferry, good idea or bad idea?"